Tina Dupuy Tina Dupuy, 10/10/2013 [Archive]

The Heritage Foundation: The Group Who Cried Individual Mandate

The Heritage Foundation: The Group Who Cried Individual Mandate

By Tina Dupuy

"[The Bush Tax Cuts] produced a more growth-oriented tax policy for the long term, helping the economy to weather current storms arising in the housing and capital markets," wrote J.D. Foster Ph.D. for the Heritage Foundation's site under the title "Make the Tax Cuts Permanent." That was back in June of 2008.

As Dr. Foster was penning that fairy tale, Lehman Brothers had just lost $2.8 billion in the second quarter of 2008. They had already laid off thousands of people. They were weeks away from total collapse. The housing bubble burst before the ink was dry on the Heritage Foundation's rosy report. Foster wrote, "Tax relief helped to restore robust economic growth following the Clinton recession."

In short: They were wrong. Really wrong. Outrageously—egregiously—shockingly wrong.

This same billionaire David Koch-affiliated group said in 2001 the Bush Tax Cuts would effectively pay off the federal debt; substantially increase family income; increase personal savings; create more job opportunities.

Seriously, pay off the federal debt. They said that. It's still on the Internet.

What the unpaid-for Bush Tax Cuts did, along with two wars lobbed onto a credit card is create more debt the Republicans now pretend is a sharknado, bubonic, mandatory abortion, Muslim, science-based, Happy Holidays, minorities-voting, greenhouse-gas-reducing, gay weddings plague.

So as credibility goes—the well-funded Heritage Foundation has very little. And they're playing a huge well-documented role in the government shutdown. Why? They oppose ObamaCare and want it defunded.

Didn't they tout the individual mandate starting in 1989? Wasn't that the conservative alternative to HillaryCare? Isn't RomneyCare in Massachusetts based on the mandatory private insurance model the Heritage Foundation had been championing for decades?

Yes. Why are they opposed to it now? Hm.

Stuart Butler, a fellow at the Heritage Foundation, in an op-ed last year denied the Heritage Foundation invented ObamaCare: "But the version of the health insurance mandate Heritage and I supported in the 1990s had three critical features. First, it was not primarily intended to push people to obtain protection for their own good, but to protect others. Like auto damage liability insurance required in most states... Second, we sought to induce people to buy coverage primarily through the carrot of a generous health credit or voucher, financed in part by a fundamental reform of the tax treatment of health coverage, rather than by a stick.

"And third, in the legislation we helped craft that ultimately became a preferred alternative to ClintonCare, the 'mandate' was actually the loss of certain tax breaks for those not choosing to buy coverage, not a legal requirement."

So Butler is saying that if ObamaCare was intended to protect others instead of for your own good, he'd support it? Because the other two he lists are in ObamaCare/The ACA: tax incentives and "loss of certain tax breaks" is basically the fine for not having insurance next year.

Is our government really shut down right now because the best think-tank-parsing they can come up with is that the motives for being covered aren't altruistic?

In a word: Yes.

The tea party/Heritage Foundation/Koch brothers trinity have co-opted the Revolutionary War's Gadsden Flag, the yellow flag with a rattle snake warning "don't tread on me." A more apt illustration would be a snake eating its own tail while accusing Obama of cannibalism.

What's worse for the country: When conservatives don't get their way—or when they do?

Now Republicans in the House are parroting the Heritage Foundation and Dr. Foster once again about the debt ceiling. Basically, that defaulting on the nation's debt—the debt the Heritage Foundation claimed would be wiped out by tax cuts they pushed—isn't that big of a deal.The title of his January directive was, "Debt Ceiling: Default Not at Issue, Federal Spending Is."

In 2008 when the sky was actually falling, the Heritage Foundation said it was sunny and reason to keep unpaid-for tax cuts (during a time of war) permanent.

In Vegas the house loves bad gamblers. There the Heritage Foundation would get their room comped and a free pass to the all-you-can-eat shrimp buffet.

But outside of a casino, their ideas are clearly not beneficial to the House. Or the rest of the country.


©Copyright 2013 TinaDupuy.com, distributed exclusively by Cagle Cartoons newspaper syndicate.

Tina Dupuy is a nationally syndicated op-ed columnist, investigative journalist, award-winning writer, stand-up comic, on-air commentator and wedge issue fan. Tina can be reached at tinadupuy@yahoo.com.

This column has been edited by the author. Representations of fact and opinions are solely those of the author.

Download Tina Dupuy's color photo - Download Tina Dupuy's black and white mug shot photo
Why not run a cartoon with the column? We recommend the cartoons below as a good compliment to Tina Dupuy's topic.
Click on the thumbnail images to preview and download the cartoons.

Related Cartoons

 Lib  Shutdown of Obama
By: Tom Janssen

October 3, 2013

 Lib  get over it
By: David Fitzsimmons

October 4, 2013

Obamacare head-banging COLOR
By: John Cole

October 3, 2013

Obamacare head-banging BW
By: John Cole

October 3, 2013

Pushy Congress
By: Christopher Weyant

October 6, 2013

Pushy Congress COLOR
By: Christopher Weyant

October 6, 2013

 Lib  TEA BRAIN color
By: Bill Day

October 4, 2013

By: Bill Day

October 4, 2013

shutdown gr
By: Hajo de Reijger

October 2, 2013

shutdown COLOR
By: Hajo de Reijger

October 2, 2013

We do not accept and will not review unsolicited submissions from cartoonists.
Sales & Information: (805) 969-2829 sales@cagle.com
Billing Information: (805) 969-2829billing@cagle.com
Technical Support: support@cagle.com

FREE cartoons for your website if you're already a paying print subscriber!
Artwork and columns are copyrighted by each creator. All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized reproduction prohibited. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service